• Login
  • Register
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us
  • Home
  • Documents
  • Activities
  • Activity Tools
    • All Tools
    • Analyzing Documents
    • Discussion Topic
    • Compare and Contrast
    • Zoom/Crop
    • White Out / Black Out
    • Spotlight
    • Finding a Sequence
    • Making Connections
    • Mapping History
    • Seeing the Big Picture
    • Weighing the Evidence
    • Interpreting Data
  • Popular Topics
    • See All
    • National History Day
    • The Constitution
    • Labor History
    • Sports: All-American
    • Rights in America
    • American Indians
    • Women's Rights
    • American Revolution
    • The Civil War
    • World War I
    • World War II
    • The Vietnam War
    • 1970s America
    • Congress
    • Amending America
    • Elections
    • What Americans Eat
    • Signatures
    • Nixon and Ford Years
  • Resources
    • Getting Started
    • Document Analysis
    • Activity-Creation Guide
    • Manage Assignments
    • iPad App
    • Presentation Materials
    • Webinars
      • Recorded Webinars
      • Live Webinars
MENU
DocsTeachThe online tool for teaching with documents, from the National Archives National Archives Foundation National Archives

Separation of Powers or Shared Powers

Weighing the Evidence

Print
Created by the National Archives
Bookmark this Activity in My Activities:
Copy this Activity to My Activities for editing:
Separation of Powers or Shared Powers

About this Activity

  • Created by:National Archives Education Team
  • Historical Era:Across Eras: Civics & Government
  • Thinking Skill:Historical Analysis & Interpretation
  • Bloom's Taxonomy:Analyzing
  • Grade Level:Middle School
Start Activity
Please use a tablet or desktop computer to use this activity.
In this activity, students will identify and draw conclusions about the relationship between the legislative, executive and judicial branches by critically analyzing primary sources. Using the scale, they will decide whether the United States government more appropriately fits the concept of "separation of powers" or "shared powers." They will formulate an opinion about each document and place it on the scale accordingly, and support their opinions with specific evidence from the primary sources.
https://docsteach.org/activities/student/separation-of-powers-or-shared-powers

Suggested Teaching Instructions

This activity may be used to conclude a unit of study into the creation of the US Constitution. The activity can be completed as a class, in small groups, in pairs, or individually. For grades 6-12. Approximate time needed is 90 minutes.

Start the lesson with a refresher of the terms "separation of powers" and "checks and balances." If students should be aware of these term's meanings, ask them to write a brief definition of the term in their own words, share their definition with a classmate, and then discuss the definitions as a group (i.e. a write, pair, share).

(Sample Definitions Checks and Balances: a system of overlapping powers of the separate branches of government that permits each branch to limit, restrain, or inform the actions of the other branches. Separation of Powers: a basic principle of American government that places different governing duties and powers among three independent and coequal branches: legislative, executive and judicial.)'

Ask students to provide an example of both "separation of powers" and "shared powers" in practice. For example, the President's ability to pardon without oversight is an example of separation of powers, while the law making power of Congress is shared with both the executive (through signing and vetoing legislation) and judicial branches (through declaring laws unconstitutional).

After discussing definitions, introduce the activity. Tell students they will be examining documents from throughout United States history to determine whether in practice our government has followed a principle of "separation of powers" or "shared powers."

Open the activity and model document analysis with one of the documents. After reading the document out-loud as a group, take a poll of students to see if they think this exemplifies "separation of powers" or "shared powers." Ask students to explain their opinions. Show how the scale works and based on the opinions of the class, place this example on the Weighing the Evidence scale.

Then tell students to analyze the remaining documents. As they analyze, students should note the particular branches associated with each document and the level of interaction between these branches within the document. Tell them to then place the document on the scale based on their opinion of which interpretation it helps support.

Special Note: As they analyze, tell students to note the overall importance of the actions they are selecting as examples of "separation of powers" and "shared powers." Rather than simply counting examples of both in action, they should be considering the scale and scope of the separation and/or shared nature. For example, while a President's exclusive pardoning power is an example of "separation of powers," does the fact that all laws require cooperation between the legislative and executive branches illustrate a greater degree of "shared powers."

Following completion of the activity, lead a class discussion on the issue. Teacher may write "separation of powers" and "shared powers" on opposite corners of the classroom and ask students to "take a stand" overall on their opinion about this issue. Question several students to explain their reasoning by citing evidence from the specific documents they analyzed.

During the discussion, direct students to some of the controversial documents included in this collection. For example, the fact the President must receive Congressional approval for confirmations (an example of “shared powers”), but can remove people from positions without approval (an example of a “separation of powers”). This discussion can include Lincoln’s suspension of habeas corpus (a Congressional power) and Franklin Roosevelt’s court-packing scheme.

Extension Activity: As an extension to this activity, ask students to create an argument writing focused on supporting either the "separation of powers" and "shared powers" thesis.

Documents in this activity

  • Attempted Override of President Richard Nixon's Veto of S. 518, an Act to Abolish the Offices of the Director and Deputy Director of the Office of Management and Budget
  • Draft of Motion Rule for Marbury v. Madison
  • Fireside Chat on Reorganization of the Judiciary
  • Gulf of Tonkin Resolution, as Introduced
  • Judgment in Brown v. Board of Education
  • Message of President Abraham Lincoln Nominating Ulysses S. Grant to Be Lieutenant General of the Army
  • Nomination of John Marshall to the Supreme Court
  • 19th Amendment to the United States Constitution
  • Presidential Proclamation 4311 of September 8, 1974, by President Gerald R. Ford granting a pardon to Richard M. Nixon.
  • President Lincoln's Proclamation Suspending the Writ of Habeas Corpus
  • Proposed Orders and Statement on Dismissal of General MacArthur
  • Roll call votes relating to the impeachment of President Andrew Johnson on Articles II, III, and XI
  • Senate Journal for the Second Session of the 77th Congress
  • Resolution to Censure Senator Joseph McCarthy
  • Telegram from Abraham Lincoln to Lt. Gen. Ulysses Grant at City Point, Virginia
  • Transcript of Message to Congress Requesting Declaration of War Against Japan
  • Veto message of President Franklin D. Roosevelt to the House of Representatives
  • [Bill to Honor Veterans] House Resolution 7786 of the 83rd Congress

CC0
To the extent possible under law, National Archives Education Team has waived all copyright and related or neighboring rights to "Separation of Powers or Shared Powers".

  • Explore Primary Source Documents
  •  
  • Discover Activities You Can Teach With
  •  
  • Create Fun & Engaging Activities
Follow us on X:X
Follow us on Facebook:facebook
Please enter a valid email address

View our webinars:youtube

Get our iPad app:apple
New Documentsshare
New Activitiesshare

The National Archives

DocsTeach is a product of the National Archives education division. Our mission is to engage, educate, and inspire all learners to discover and explore the records of the American people preserved by the National Archives.

The National Archives and Records Administration is the nation's record keeper. We save documents and other materials created in the course of business conducted by the U.S. Federal government that are judged to have continuing value. We hold in trust for the public the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, and the Bill of Rights — but also the records of ordinary citizens — at our locations around the country.
  • All Education Programs
  • Student Visits
  • Distance Learning
  • Professional Development
  • National Archives Museum
  • Presidential Libraries
  • Archives.gov
  • National Archives Foundation




Creative Commons License

Except where otherwise noted, DocsTeach is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License. Primary source documents included on this site generally come from the holdings of the National Archives and are in the public domain, except as noted. Teaching activities on this site have received the CC0 Public Domain Dedication; authors have waived all copyright and related rights to the extent possible under the law. See our legal and privacy page for full terms and conditions.
Safest and most reliable Czech online casinos! isitfair.eu – a trusted platform with expertly ratings & reviews, and top choise exclusive bonuses for Czech players.